My Crash Attorneys MCA mark

Fault & Liability

What happens if the other driver lies about how the crash happened?

Short answer

A false account does not end your claim — it shifts the case onto physical evidence. Insurers do not decide fault by vote; when the two versions conflict, the damage patterns, scene photographs, video, vehicle data, witnesses and the crash report determine which story the evidence can support. Your job is to preserve that evidence quickly and to avoid changing or guessing about details in your own statements.

Written by the My Crash Attorneys Editorial TeamUpdated September 4, 2026

Step 1 of 9

No Fee Unless We Win

Get this answered for your case

Free. Confidential. Most people finish in under a minute.

What happened?

Free case reviewNo obligationAvailable 24/7

Rather talk? (866) SOPHIE-1

What Georgia law says

Georgia negligence claims are proven by evidence, and fault is apportioned among all contributors under O.C.G.A. § 51-12-33, with recovery reduced by the injured person's share and barred at 50 percent. Where the other driver's conduct violated a traffic safety statute — for example following too closely under O.C.G.A. § 40-6-49 or failing to yield when turning left under O.C.G.A. § 40-6-71 — the violation can supply the standard of care. Georgia also requires drivers to report qualifying crashes to law enforcement under O.C.G.A. § 40-6-273, and a false report to police carries its own consequences.

What this means after an accident

Practically, a dishonest account usually helps the honest party once evidence lands, because inconsistencies compound. What hurts a claim is an injured person whose own account drifts — a guessed speed, an estimated distance, or a detail added weeks later that the photographs contradict.

How this actually works

What to do: write your own account the same day while it is exact, and mark what you do not know rather than filling gaps. Preserve the vehicles photographically before repair, because impact geometry is often decisive. Chase video immediately — business, residential, transit and dashboard footage is commonly overwritten within days or weeks. Get witnesses' names and phone numbers, since an independent witness usually resolves a two-story dispute. Read the crash report for factual errors and ask the investigating agency about a supplemental report where something is wrong. If the insurers deadlock and the claim is denied on liability, the dispute can still be resolved in litigation, where sworn testimony, subpoenaed records and phone data replace the phone-call version of events. In serious cases, a reconstruction expert can establish speeds and positions from the physical evidence alone.

What you should do

  1. 01Write your own dated account today, marking clearly what you do not know.
  2. 02Photograph both vehicles before any repair, from every angle.
  3. 03Ask nearby businesses and homes about camera footage within the first week.
  4. 04Get witness names and phone numbers, and ask them to confirm what they saw in writing.
  5. 05Read the crash report and ask the agency to correct factual errors.

Important exceptions

Some limits apply: whether a citation, a guilty plea or a no-contest plea can be used, and for what purpose, depends on Georgia evidence rules; insurance fraud allegations are handled separately from your injury claim; and a genuine mistake by the other driver is treated differently from deliberate deception. If the other driver's story changes over time, both versions are usually usable.

When an attorney may help

Once liability is disputed, the claim becomes an evidence project with deadlines. Legal help matters for sending preservation letters, obtaining video and vehicle data, and taking sworn testimony that a phone call with an adjuster cannot produce.

Next step

What happens next?

  1. 1

    Tell us what happened

    Complete the short case review or call MCA. It takes a couple of minutes and costs nothing.

  2. 2

    We review the accident

    Our intake team identifies the location, accident type, injuries and any immediate issues.

  3. 3

    If we can help, you meet your legal team

    Your attorney is licensed in the jurisdiction handling your matter.

No Fee Unless We Win

Get a straight answer about your own case

Call MCAStart Case Review